PESC 
Professional Engineers South Cumbria

 
 
 
Talks arranged for 2024 (reports courtesy of  Ian Palmer)

 


10/1/24  “Forensic Investigation as a Career” Part 2”   Isobel Colclough, told the audience of  60+, that she gaining a degree in Chemical Engineering (1989) and did research on Composting at Agricultural College before joining Greater Manchester Police  (GMP) as Crime Scene Investigator (CSI) in 1996.  Here she was able to attend a number of internal training courses to learn the basics of crime scene investigations and lead some investigations.  Gun crime (hence, the name ‘Gunchester’) and crime gangs were prevalent then but were now replaced by drugs.  In 2009, she joined UCLAN to lecture on the subject, including Archaeology and Anthropology,  and gained an M.Sc. in Fire Investigations.  In 2018, while still at UCLAN, she also worked for GMP and was in charge of the Longsight Area.  In 2018, she joined the UK Crime Training Service, with was trained in photography, forensic techniques and taking finger prints.  She subsequently set herself up as an Independent Consultant, working mainly on teaching and auditing Crime Procedures in UK and in Afghanistan (dangerous), Iraq, Nigeria, The Gambia, Falkland Islands and Libya.  International Humanitarian  Law covered Genocide, Crimes Against Humanity, War Crimes and Aggression and were covered by ISO Procedures 17020 (2012) and 17025 (2017).
You did not need a degree to be a CSI, just have an enquiring mind, problem solving skills and lateral thinking ability, but did need a STEM subject degree for Forensic Research.  The most important thing was to get into employment and then apply for internal promotions to progress your career.

7/2/24    “Living On The Moon, Living Off The Moon”   Dr. Joshua Resera, of Imperial College, London, told the audience of 120+ that a ‘resource’ was a natural concentration of a useful material and a ‘reserve’ was a resource that could be exploited economically.  It was prohibitively costly to carry everything up from Earth but different types of asteroids had limited ranges of materials and the Moon, formed by a collision with Earth, had all Earth’s elements.  Mars was similarly endowed with volcanic rocks, but unlike the Moon, also had sedimentary rocks. 
The Moon rotated once in 27 Earth days so each ‘lunar day and night’ was 13½ days long.  Temperatures varied from +127 to -173oC, which was too cold for batteries, so energy at night would have to be from nuclear decay heat.  As there was no water on the Moon (or Mars), recovery of minerals would have to be via dry processes, e.g. comminution, sieving, vibration and magnetic or electrostatic separation.  Gravity-driven processes might also be possible.  Imperial College was undertaking research into dry processing in the more arid parts of Australia. 
The lunar highlands were the light parts of the Moon and the Mare the dark areas.  The regolith was very fine grained grit, sized from 0-1mm, with an average of 72μm; this proved to be a real problem for the 1970’s astronauts as the particles ‘got everywhere’ and threatened the rubber seals between their (removable) helmets and spacesuits.  Coarse fibre filtration followed by hepafiltration would be needed.  It was cohesive, electrostatically charged and, when disturbed, could spread a long way over the lunar surface.  The regolith consisted of agglutinates, breccias, pyroclastic glass beads and rock fragments, resulting from incessant bombardment.  The low gravity (1/6th Earth’s) would be a problem, e.g. an astronaut digging in the regolith could exert only 1/6th of his mass on the spade!  However, manufacture in low gravity could give products which could not be made on Earth, such as single crystals.
Several nations had landed probes on the Moon and there was an International Treaty prohibiting colonisation of the Moon, etc. but it was ambiguous on Space Resource Utilisation (SRU) and this could lead to friction in the future.

28/2/24  “A595 Grizebeck Road Improvement”  Will Storey (of Story Contracting) and Ian Roberts (of the Design Authority) told the audience of c.110 that in 2018, two proposals were tabled; one (A) was to widen the existing road from Chapels through the farmyard and build a new road (with cycle lanes) to join the A5092 W. of the present junction at Grizebeck, and the other (B) was a completely new road, E. of the farm through/over Pan Hill to join the other new road up to the new junction.  At review, B was chosen.  This would involve taking a major slice off the sandstone Pan Hill and use the spoil as infill for the new road to the junction plus an underpass for farm traffic, an over bridge for the old road, badger tunnel, bat and owl provision.  The speakers explained how the excavation and building of the new road would be done to maintain traffic access, connect with sewers, electricity and telephone services and provide pondage for rainwater runoff from the new road.  A great deal of planning had gone in to minimise disruption and meet ecological needs.  Final approval was expected soon for an Aug. ‘24 start and Mar. ‘26ish completion. 

13/3/24  “Nuclear Powered Hydrogen Production” Professor Tim Abrams told the audience of c. 120 that the National Grid had the duty to supply electricity to the whole of the UK @ 50 Hz ± ½Hz.  This meant matching power generation with demand.  However, we were now relying on large amounts of renewables (wind and solar), which were variable in supply.  On the other side of the equation, demand was also variable.  Domestic needs rose from overnight at breakfast time, fell during the day and rose again towards teatime and further in the evening.  There could be sudden peaks, e.g. in advertising breaks during popular programmes.  Short term peak surpluses and / or demands could be met by pumped storage and battery facilities.  Base load generation could not be varied quickly, without damage to equipment; however, the destination of the power generated could be changed from one usage to another at the flick of a switch.  One possible application would be to run base load at the optimum level and divert excess power to manufacture H2 gas.  The gas would be stored on an interim basis and reacted with biological crops, grown with atmospheric CO2 to produce liquid hydrocarbon fuel, e.g. AvGas.  The CO2 produced, when the AvGas was burnt, would be returned to the atmosphere; it would not be new CO2 but recycled existing atmospheric CO2.  The H2 could be obtained by electrolysing water or dissociating it at high temperature (c. 850oC).  The Teesside AGR could be used as a Test Plant.
Giving the VoT, Ian said that, in WW2, the Germans had reacted CO + H2 (Water Gas) to make liquid fuel for the ME262 jet engined planes using the Fischer Tropsch Process; this process could be varied to react CO2 (from the atmosphere) with H2.

10/4/24   “The Last Battlewagons; The King George V Class in Combat 1940-45”  Dr. Scott Lindgren told the audience of c.70 that the Treaty of Versailles ended WW1 and the Treaties of Washington (1922) and London (2) (1930 & ’36) defined warship building for GB, US, FR and JP.  In 1937, building started on the KGV Class to pre-designs (35kT, 14” guns, 28kts & 1400 men).  These were very good ships, with good side and deck armour and the guns were very effective.  One weakness was the mounting of the gun turrets on the ships, which was too flexible and was affected by heat, cold and stormy weather so that seldom did all guns fire together in a broadside.  Quadruple 14” gun turrets all built in Barrow but mounted on weak parts of hull.  Service in 1940-’45:-
King George V: Home fleet, Atlantic Convoys, Sinking Bismarck (with Rodney), Arctic Convoys, Med. bombardments, Pacific Fleet, at Japanese surrender in Tokyo Bay 1945.
Prince of Wales: Atlantic convoys, Denmark Strait (seriously damaged Bismarck but was damaged herself), repaired, Malaysia (attacked by waves of torpedo bombers, 1st torpedo hit hull where port outer shaft exited hull (critical), sunk with Repulse).
Duke of York: Home fleet, Atlantic convoys, Med. to support W. African landings, Arctic convoys, 26/12/43 North Cape sank Scharnhorst, more Arctic convoys, Pacific fleet, at Japanese surrender.
Anson:  Never fired main armament in anger, Home fleet, arctic convoys, Pacific fleet, at Japanese surrender.
Howe:  Home fleet, Arctic convoys, bombardment in Med., Flag of UK Pacific fleet, shot down a kamikaze plane, at Japanese surrender.
KGV Class was highly successful and last of the battleships, replaced by carriers, whose aircraft had longer offensive reaches.










  








11/9/24    “Finding Life Beyond Our Solar System with The James Webb Space 
Telescope”  Addressing an audience of c.80, Robin said that single-celled life had existed from soon after the planet had cooled up to the present day as Archaea and Bacteria, Eukaryotes appeared in mid-life and Intelligent life was a latecomer.  Single celled organisms (extremophiles) had colonised areas of extreme heat, cold, acidity, radiation, deep underground and possibly even the mid-atmosphere of Venus.  Such organisms could exist today on the some of the moons of Jupiter and Saturn and Nasa’s rovers had found positive signs on Mars.  Using the JWST and other instruments, the atmospheric constituents and conditions on exoplanets could be determined to look for the chemicals associated with life but nothing positive and no free oxygen had yet been found, though we knew of only c.5000 exoplanets.  There was the possibility of life being based on Silicon, which is chemically similar to carbon but we do not know of any.

25/9/24    “Bahamas – The Story of a Steam Locomotive”  Peter Skellon told the audience of c.40 that :Bahamas’ was a Jubilee Class engine, designed by W. Stainier, built in 1934 and served with distinction from 1935-67, 2 years longer than her design life.  She worked out of many depots all over England, Wales and Scotland, including Carlisle involving trips to / from Barrow.  He explained how the boiler worked with the exhaust steam from the cylinders exiting the blast pipe into the smoke box to create a vacuum to draw air into the fire grate and combustion products through the heat exchanger tubes (boiler).  One development had been to bifurcate the blast pipe to feed a double chimney, which considerably improved the engine’s overall efficiency.  The Clean Air Act of 1952 was the start of the end for steam as BR turned to diesel and electric traction.  In 1967, a group of volunteer enthusiasts raised £3k to buy Bahamas from BR and then £900+k (including a £776k Lottery grant) to restore her; this involved the volunteers learning new skills, e.g. riveting, welding, plating, etc.  She had become a major attraction in Steam Excursion Specials all over the country, earning considerable income for her Trust, based with the Keithly & Worth Valley Railway.  The provision of coal supplies and new safety regulations, e.g. remote locking of doors on vintage carriages, presented future problems.

9/10/24    “MNZ Cluster: Permanent Storage of CO2 in Depleted Morecambe Bay Gas Fields” Jack Richards, Spirit Energy, unable to come.  He had apologised and offered to give the talk at a later date.  We pencilled in 26/2/25; IP to contact him.

IP talk instead:-
“Carbon Dioxide – Friend or Foe?”  Ian Palmer told the audience of 50 about the origin, chemistry and bonding of CO2 , strength of C=O double bond and its historic role in keeping Earth warm and its role in supporting the evolution of life, the long term historical role of [CO2] and its role since start of Industrial Revolution (1750) in Climate Change.  Described photosynthesis and its essential contribution to life.  Discussed problems due to Climate Change, ways to mitigate its effects, including CCS and CCU, and advocated a long term CCU solution.

23/10/24    “Dorothée Pullinger, M.B.E. – A Life in Automobiles, Munitions and Other Engineering Enterprises”  Nina Baker told the audience of c.60 that DP (1894-1986) was the eldest daughter of Thomas Pullinger (TP); born and living in France, she took a keen interest in her Father’s bicycle making business, which moved on from making pedal cycles to motor-assisted ones.  At age 8, the family moved to England and TP moved into making cars, initially buying French cars and replacing components with British equivalents.  DP attended Loughborough High School as a boarder and later evening classes to learn engineering.  TP became the General Manager of Arrol-Johnson (1907-26), which took them to Glasgow; DP worked in the Drawing & Design Office and on the shop floor.  TP acquired a licence to manufacture Astro-Daimler areo-engines and, by the start of WW1, DP was a competent engineer.  In 1915, there was a catastrophic shortage of shells for the guns on the Western Front.  In Barrow, there were French-speaking women making and filling shells and bi-lingual DP was ideally suited to organise them and the English-speaking ones; she had to recruit women, train them, organise their accommodation and manage up to 7000 by the end of the war; she was awarded an MBE.  After the war, she returned to her Father’s business, which was now building cars unprofitably.  They built a new factory nearby at Tongland, reduced the number of models and replaced the ‘craft manufacture’ (one team building the whole car) with the American ‘production line system’ and produced the ‘Galloway’ range of cars, a saloon & a coupé – 2 models remain in museums and the saloon was driven by the Dr. Snoddy character in the ‘Dr. Finlay’ TV series).  DP became a Member of IMechE and, in 1946, she moved with her family to Guernsey on to a farm.  She then set up a Laundry Service in the locality and died in 1986.

13/11/24    “Staying Alive: Debunking Common Misconceptions About Body Armour”  Dr. Eluned Lewis listed 7 misconceptions, for the 55 person audience, and then comprehensively demolished them with a very, detailed talk.  Body armour was usually made of a combination of materials, it would not stop all types of attack but reduced the severity of any injury; chain mail was the best anti-stab protection but would only slow down a bullet (dissipate it’s energy) to reduce deep penetration and ‘buy time’ for medics to save the life.  Silk undies were very useful reducing injuries when a soldier stepped on an IED.  Kevlar® was important for both vehicle and personal protection but the armour must not hamper the user’s movement.  Women were not ‘small men’ and required special types of protection as well as garments to wear for, say, a 12-14hr. patrol in an armoured vehicle (allowing for calls of nature).  Race was important as the faces of Gurkas were different shapes to those of Europeans needing unique eye and face protection.  Police faced different threats to soldiers.  All protective products had to be proved by specialist laboratories before use.  Excellent talk.
  


2.1     Attendance Summary
In 2023 / 24, 690 people had attended 8 PESC lectures – an average of 86 per lecture.
In 2022 / 23, 465 people had attended 7 PESC lectures – an average of 66 per lecture.
In 2021 / 22, 180 people had attended 6 PESC lectures – an average of 30 per lecture.
In 2019 – 2021, there were no lectures due to the Covid pandemic.
In 2018 / 19, 1135 people had attended 11 PESC lectures – an average of 103 per lecture.